site.soft-404
A clearly non-existent URL returns HTTP 200 instead of 404.
What to change
Return a real 404 (or 410) status for unknown routes; otherwise search engines index error pages and waste crawl budget.
The documentation on developers.google.comA finding of this rule on a page carries the exact edits for that page: the markup it quotes, and what to write instead.
When it runs
Runs on a crawl or a build directory. A warning is a problem that costs a page ranking, clicks or citations. Each finding takes 5 points off the page's score.
The severity here is the rule's usual one: a finding can be raised or lowered when the page gives a reason.
Run it, or skip it
Check a page for this rule alone, after a fix for instance:
npx @rivi-software/agentic-seo-check crawl https://example.com --rule site.soft-404
Or from an assistant, with the MCP tool seo_crawl_site:
{
"url": "https://example.com",
"rules": [
"site.soft-404"
]
}
To leave it out of an audit, pass --disable site.soft-404 on the command, or disableRules: ["site.soft-404"] to a tool.
More in Site-wide checks
All 49 rules- Warning
site.duplicate-descriptionsSeveral indexable pages share the same meta description. - Info
site.duplicate-h1Several pages share the same <h1>. - Warning
site.duplicate-contentPages with identical or near-identical body text. - Info
site.deep-pagesPages that are more than the configured number of clicks (default 3) from the start URL. - Warning
site.http-not-redirectedThe http:// version of the site does not redirect to https://. - Warning
site.host-variant-not-redirectedThe www/non-www variant of the host does not redirect to the main host. - Warning
site.hreflang-no-return-linkhreflang alternates do not link back to the page that references them. - Warning
site.broken-external-linksExternal links point to URLs that return 4xx/5xx or fail to load.